Infinite Outdoors logo
Property photo

Como, Park County, Colorado

Fishing

4.73

Bar Star Lake

Adventure Details

Reservation fee

$9.99

Price per person

$134.99

Total

$0.00

Amenities

Stillwater, Bathroom, Guides Allowed, Boat Launch, Partial Phone Service

Acreage

0

Fish Species

Brook Trout, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout, Tiger Trout

Notes from the landowner

For 2025, fishing hours will end at 4 PM each day.

Bar Star Lake is a hidden retreat in South Park Valley just outside Como, Colorado. Only 1.5 hours from Denver, 45 minutes from Breckenridge, and 1.5 hours from Colorado Springs, Bar Star Lake is a convenient day trip destination.

Bar Star Lake (Tarryall Creek Reservoir #1) is a 30-acre mountain lake stocked with both big fish and mid-range fish to account for both quality and numbers. The catch and release policy ensures a private fishing experience and preserves the natural habitat.

This lake is a true gem—fertile and healthy, offering the fish plenty of food to grow fast and strong. The upside? These trout are big and healthy. But here's the catch— the fishing here can be more technical, and the fish can be a bit pickier. But once you crack the code, the reward is huge. You might not reel in big numbers, but you’ll reel in big Trout.

Whether you prefer small boats, wading, or shore fishing, This property welcomes anglers of all levels from May to October. The lake offers easy access for both walkwaders and float anglers, with flat and accessible parking.

Families are welcome, however, young anglers (12 and under) must wear life jackets at all times while fishing from a boat or the shore. For those seeking expert guidance, Valholl Ranch provides access to experienced guides through the property owner, ensuring a fulfilling and educational fishing experience, just reach out to Infinite Outdoors and we can help get that set up for you.

Bar Star Lake is home to trout ranging from 14 to 20 inches. Anglers with 9′ 5wt, 9′ 6wt, 9’6″ 6wt, and 9′ 7wt rods are well-equipped as well as 3x and up tippet and leaders. Recommended flies include scuds in orange and hopper-dropper setups. This property is the perfect setup to get out on the water during those high run-off times when the rivers are raging. You do not have to give up days on the water, just book Bar Star Lake instead.

Although we typically get your booking approved within a few hours, please allow up to 1 business day for booking confirmations.

Due to agricultural concerns, dogs are not allowed on this property.

Corporate Events: Corporate and large group events are allowed and encouraged on this property. Valholl Ranch also has on-site shooting ranges and can offer your group Blast and Cast options.

All fishing must be booked through Infinite Outdoors.

Fishing Hours

Sunrise to 4 PM

Fishing Information

Don’t forget your local fishing license, you can grab one online here.

Check out the most up-to-date fishing report here.

Contact our area fly shop partner, Arbor Anglers or Flies & Lies, for the most up-to-date hatch and fly information.

Know the local regulations.

Fishing Hours: Sunrise to 4 PM.

Fishing Season: May - October. A great time to fish this property is during spring runoff as it is not affected.

Rod recommendation: 89' 5wt, 9' 6wt, 9'6" 6wt, and 9' 7wt rods are well-equipped as well as 3x and up tippet and leaders.

Boat Information

Float tubes and small boats are allowed, but only human-powered or electric motors are permitted. Safety is a priority, and all float anglers must wear life vests.

FAQs

NO
No. Once parked, all access is restricted to foot only.
Porta-Potty, Boat Launch, Partial Phone Service, Warming Shed
YES
Towns, hotels, RV parks?
NO
For properties listed as "Community Adventures" there is the possibility that a limited number of other anglers can be on the property at the same time. Just a heads up, some of our spots have other leases that might have anglers casting their lines too. So, hit 'request to book' and we'll make sure to confirm the availability before you pack your gear!
We think it's important to mentor the next generation of anglers. Youth between the ages of 13 and 17 are 50% off for all fishing and small game when you reserve on the Infinite Outdoors app. However, kids 13-17 will need to have an Infinite Outdoors Membership. Youth 12 and under are free and do not need a membership but must follow all property rules.
No, most of our property listings are available to Infinite Outdoors Members without a pass. If you plan on fishing on a regular basis talk to our support team and see if a pass might make sense.
Not all properties have signs, so be sure to check the property boundaries and information in the Infinite Outdoors app.
Access your adventure on the IO app before heading out the door, all the information and maps will be on the app so you don't need service to navigate your adventure. Also all property maps will download offline onto your app so you can always see where you are on the property, even without service.
We can't guarantee you'll catch fish every time—fishing always comes with a bit of unpredictability due to factors like weather and fish behavior. However, we do everything we can to boost your chances! We offer information on local fly shops so you can get the best tips and gear recommendations. As for the size of the fish, it really depends on where you're fishing. We aim to connect you with spots where you have a good shot at landing some great catches, but it's all part of the Do-It-Yourself fly fishing adventure!
Download and use the Infinite Outdoors app for directions to the property, boundary lines, access points, and more. These maps can be found in the adventure layer on the app home screen or in your list of adventures under the "Adventures" tab.
Adventures must be cancelled 48 hours or more prior to the trip. Any cancellations made within 48 hours will result in partial or full charges.
Yes, each active angler on the property must be an active Infinite Outdoors member and must be invited, and accepted, to the adventure through the platform.
Non anglers require prior approval. Once approved they must still be IO members but may be subject to reduced price or free outdoorsman fee. If this applies to you, please reach out to IO.
No. You may park and begin to fish as soon as you arrive. The landowners are typically on site and greet you at some point.
Your downloaded adventure and map in the IO app is your proof of booking. Be prepared to present it upon request.
Unavailable dates may be due to properties already being booked to capacity, landowners have not yet made dates available, or we are resting the property for conservation purposes. Feel free to contact an Infinite Outdoors member or support team if this issue arises.
property map
Conversation
Reviews

ca

Jul 12, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Another great day at Bar Star Lake. Landed about 8, including two massive rainbows and several large browns. Small black leach, balanced leach, and especially black with white "eyes" boobies were effective. Used a pontoon belly boat. Best action in the vicinity of the aerators. Thanks, Eric!

bg

Jun 13, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

I fished Bar Star Lake 2 weeks ago and managed only one hookup (did not land her). This time, I hooked 10-12 trout and landed most of them. Although I don't take my fish out of the water, at least 3 of the Rainbows were around 24" and THICK! The rest of the trout were a mix of Brown and Rainbow trout and ranged from 12-20". I strongly recommend 3x leaders to bring the fish to net more quickly. Leeches and chironomid patterns were the ticket.

bg

Jun 3, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Had a fun day at Bar Star before dark clouds, rain, and strong winds sent me on my way. I hooked up fairly early but lost the fish straight away. And had no other fish action. But the bald eagle soaring overhead, and a single pronghorn silhouetted on the ridge were thrill enough for me. It was a wonderful day.

similar properties